Nikon 18-200 VR Review

Nikon 18-200 VR Review

“WONDERFUL lens… NOT a cure all”

nikon nikkor 18-200

Some of the reviews you’ve read on the internet are a little over-hyped. And some of them, or at least some portions of them, are not. I’m using this lens on a D50… Great results so far.

Well, you know the specs by now. two ED elements, three aspheric, Silent Wave Motor, VR II, Internal Focusing (NO movement of the front element!) and great zoom range (beware, this thing gets obnoxiously huge when zoomed in to 200. It just looks plain silly, especially with the lens hood, which I left in the box anyway.)

I am not going to go into detailed specifics of the distortion, since that’s been dealt with better by Ken Rockwell, Thom Hogan and others (EXCELLENT reviews… seek them out…). But it’s severe enough at the wide end that you will probably want to correct it (as best you can) in Photoshop. In real-life shooting, it isn’t a huge deal. (UPDATE: In real life shooting of hundreds of images so far, I’ve found NOT ONE SINGLE INSTANCE where I wanted to bother “fixing” it. I repeat… There is distortion, but it is NOT a problem.) I find that when I zoom in to 24 it is totally usable to all intents and purposes, and if I REALLY want to use something you shot at 18, unless there are some REALLY straight lines in it you might have no need of correction. So, in short, the distortion is there, but so what. It’s bound to be in a lens of this range.

Some other reviewers report better resistance to flare than I am experiencing. It is still pretty good in a lens of this many elements, but it is hardly “nonexistent” as some have reported. (UPDATE! I have had only ONE image “ruined” by flare. It was pointed at the sun. Flare is excellent on this lens!) Mine is made in Thailand and earlier ones in Japan. I hope that I got the same quality as the lucky early adopters, but this could account for that difference. I still don’t use the lens hood because I step the filter threads up to 77 and don’t want to take off my UV filter ever time I use it.

I actually find I can stack my polarizer on top of my UV (which is on a 72 – 77mm step-up ring – Curse you Nikon for not making the threads 77!) and STILL use this lens with no real vignetting at 24 and above. Now I REALLY want a 12-24, but that’s a whole other story (don’t have the dough).

Focus is LUDICROUSLY fast, either manually or auto. The AF-S seems to be the real deal in this lens, with a real Silent Wave Motor, unlike some “partial” AF-S lenses NIkon has been selling lately. (Low light is a problem sometimes… duh…)

Now, I took two stars off for the distortion (necessary, I admit), and the slight chromatic aberrations I’m getting on slight over-exposures, and the reduced speed as you zoom out to 200, but it gets BOTH of those back easily for the INCREDIBLE VR technology and the fact that I have had NOTHING but excellent images come out of it. It kinda eats batteries for lunch compared with not using VR, but it’s still usuallly lasting me at least 300 exposures with an external SB600 as flash. (why haven’t you gotten a backup battery yet?!?). I actually shot some indoor 1600 stuff hand-held all the way at 200mm (300 equiv) and 1/40 or 1/50. AMAZING! I understand it works well in low light at the wide end too. Haven’t tried any available darkness landscapes yet, so I can’t say.

So… It IS a do all and be all lens! Maybe not for the pro, but certainly for the guy who wants to take some great shots and especially the guy who doesn’t want to miss a shot because he’s changing lenses (and letting dust into his camera…)

It’s a great lens. Just buy it!

More Nikon 18-200mm Reviews from Amazon:

Check out Amazon.com for more reviews of Nikon’s 18-200mm, it has more consumer reviews and reports than any other site online:

reviews of nikon 18-200mm

Price Range: $XXX to $779.39
Best Price: $$ Click To See Today’s Sale Price $$


Nikon 18-200 VR Review By P. Hamm "uberflavn" (Virginia, USA)
- More Reviews from Amazon.com

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: